US adds new fees, charges for drinks, ends all elite bonus miles (Merged Threads)
#181

Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: ZRH
Posts: 659
I hadn't seen this before. Terrible. The RDU club is a welcome refuge in that airport and the staff there is terrific.
Last edited by goheelswks; Jun 13, 2008 at 9:51 am
#182




Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: DCA/IAD
Programs: AA EXP; 1W Emerald; HHonors Diamond; Marriott Gold; UA dirt
Posts: 8,974
"-- First-Checked-Bag Fee: The airline announced plans to implement a
first-checked-bag service fee of $15. The new fee goes into effect
for tickets booked on or after July 9, 2008, and will apply to all
flights within the U.S., to/from Canada, Latin America, and the
Caribbean. The airline will waive the fee for its most frequent
customers including: all Dividend Miles Preferred members (Silver,
Gold, Platinum and Chairman's Preferred), confirmed First Class
and Envoy passengers at time of check in, and Star Alliance Silver
and Gold status members. The following customers will also be
exempt from paying the fee: military personnel on active duty,
unaccompanied minors and passengers checking assistive devices."
Tickets bookd on or after July 9. Does that mean travel July 9 or make the reservation July 9?
So if I make a reservation today for travel on August 1, do I pay the baggage fee?
first-checked-bag service fee of $15. The new fee goes into effect
for tickets booked on or after July 9, 2008, and will apply to all
flights within the U.S., to/from Canada, Latin America, and the
Caribbean. The airline will waive the fee for its most frequent
customers including: all Dividend Miles Preferred members (Silver,
Gold, Platinum and Chairman's Preferred), confirmed First Class
and Envoy passengers at time of check in, and Star Alliance Silver
and Gold status members. The following customers will also be
exempt from paying the fee: military personnel on active duty,
unaccompanied minors and passengers checking assistive devices."
Tickets bookd on or after July 9. Does that mean travel July 9 or make the reservation July 9?
So if I make a reservation today for travel on August 1, do I pay the baggage fee?
#183
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Programs: DL Silver, UA Silver, Marriott Lifetime Silver, IHG Plat, Hilton Silver
Posts: 5,695
"-- First-Checked-Bag Fee: The airline announced plans to implement a
first-checked-bag service fee of $15. The new fee goes into effect
for tickets booked on or after July 9, 2008, and will apply to all
flights within the U.S., to/from Canada, Latin America, and the
Caribbean. The airline will waive the fee for its most frequent
customers including: all Dividend Miles Preferred members (Silver,
Gold, Platinum and Chairman's Preferred), confirmed First Class
and Envoy passengers at time of check in, and Star Alliance Silver
and Gold status members. The following customers will also be
exempt from paying the fee: military personnel on active duty,
unaccompanied minors and passengers checking assistive devices."
Tickets bookd on or after July 9. Does that mean travel July 9 or make the reservation July 9?
So if I make a reservation today for travel on August 1, do I pay the baggage fee?
first-checked-bag service fee of $15. The new fee goes into effect
for tickets booked on or after July 9, 2008, and will apply to all
flights within the U.S., to/from Canada, Latin America, and the
Caribbean. The airline will waive the fee for its most frequent
customers including: all Dividend Miles Preferred members (Silver,
Gold, Platinum and Chairman's Preferred), confirmed First Class
and Envoy passengers at time of check in, and Star Alliance Silver
and Gold status members. The following customers will also be
exempt from paying the fee: military personnel on active duty,
unaccompanied minors and passengers checking assistive devices."
Tickets bookd on or after July 9. Does that mean travel July 9 or make the reservation July 9?
So if I make a reservation today for travel on August 1, do I pay the baggage fee?
#184




Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: PHL/EWR
Programs: AA MM; UA-S; HH-D; Marriott-LTP
Posts: 227
"The airline's frequent flyer program continues to be one of the best programs in the industry and presents the most generous upgrade opportunities". Oof.
Are they out of their minds?! Just how does it continue to be one of the best? I know it's Friday the 13th, but is this April fools too?
How generous can the upgrades possibly be when, for example, I don't think I was upgraded even 50% of the time when I was a Chairman? Oh but since the upgrades are generous, maybe the first class capacity is increasing. Ah, I crack me up.
And no more bonus miles? o.k., I guess elites should simply be happy they get to board first (now increasingly more important since people will engage in carry-on more often in lieu of the 1st checked bag fee) -- or has that been eliminated as well?
Sheesh...
Are they out of their minds?! Just how does it continue to be one of the best? I know it's Friday the 13th, but is this April fools too?
How generous can the upgrades possibly be when, for example, I don't think I was upgraded even 50% of the time when I was a Chairman? Oh but since the upgrades are generous, maybe the first class capacity is increasing. Ah, I crack me up.
And no more bonus miles? o.k., I guess elites should simply be happy they get to board first (now increasingly more important since people will engage in carry-on more often in lieu of the 1st checked bag fee) -- or has that been eliminated as well?

Sheesh...
#185
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Commuting around the mid-atlantic and rust-belt on any number of RJs
Programs: TSA Random Selectee Platinum, * Gold, SPG/HH/MR mid-tier, and a tiny bag of pretzels.
Posts: 9,255
No, I am not kidding.
I am not suggesting it is your job to make US profitable; I am suggesting that complaining about what they are doing wrong while you have no idea what would be better is in bad faith. Imagine complaining that a steak isn't cooked the right amount of time and then when asked if you'd like it cooked more or cooked less, you replied "I don't know, I'm just complaining that you should do it better!"
I am not suggesting it is your job to make US profitable; I am suggesting that complaining about what they are doing wrong while you have no idea what would be better is in bad faith. Imagine complaining that a steak isn't cooked the right amount of time and then when asked if you'd like it cooked more or cooked less, you replied "I don't know, I'm just complaining that you should do it better!"
There is zero compelling reason (absent residence in PHX or CLT) for loyalty to US. None. Everyone else offers a better product, more perks, or less nickel and dime crap.
The key to all of this, as has been mentioned for years, is fares that are reasonable (and yes, that in adjusted for the cost of fuel). HP apparently did this right before the merger, and lost their mind thereafter.
#186
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: PHL
Programs: US Plat, SPG Gold
Posts: 1,331
I couldn't be more disappointed since I'm someone, like BostonMark, who has been somewhat of a defender of US.
#187
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: PHL
Programs: Former long-time US GP; now AA dirt
Posts: 4,904
If US does not think they have a sustainable business model, and they do not think their business model will become sustainable in light of their projections of future fuel prices, the best option for their shareholders is to Chapter 7 immediately and try to preserve as much capital as possible.
While Chapter 7 may be the best move to allow US to survive, wouldn't Chapter 7 wipe out all shareholder value? Or does it depend on the structuring?
#188




Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: DCA / WAS
Programs: DL 2+ million/PM, YX, Marriott Plt, *wood gold, HHonors, CO Plt, UA, AA EXP, WN, AGR
Posts: 9,386
Given the assets here and the weakness of the industry, I can't see the assets having enough value to pay all the creditors....
#189




Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: BZN
Programs: AA:LT Platinum DL:LT Gold UA:1P MAR:LT Titanium
Posts: 8,292
Alienating the only group of people with less elasticity in their travel plans is stupid when fares are,as you point out, going to have to go up (and thus drive out the people with elasticity in their travel plans)...The key to all of this, as has been mentioned for years, is fares that are reasonable (and yes, that in adjusted for the cost of fuel). HP apparently did this right before the merger, and lost their mind thereafter.
#190




Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Programs: UA 1K 1MMer & LT UC (when flying UA); Hyatt Credit Cardist; HHonors Gold; Marriott Gold via UA 1K
Posts: 7,146
#191
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: LAX/TPE
Programs: United 1K, JAL Sapphire, SPG Lifetime Platinum, National Executive Elite, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 47,263
Chapter 11 is re-organization. Chapter 7 definitely wipes out shareholder value, while Chapter 11 could, depending on the restructuring format vis a vis the issuance of new stock.
#192
Join Date: Jun 2008
Programs: [was] US Chaiman, AA, Hilton Silver, Mariott Gold, DL Gold, UA Silver
Posts: 17
So, again, why will others NOT match the "bonus mileage kill"?
So, I was about to compose that email to coair.com to "status-beg", but then I thought: what really prevents all others from matching it?
There was a HUGE outcry when AA started "first bag for $15" policy and many predicted that nobody sane will match it - and now everybody is.
So, again, why will others NOT match the "bonus mileage
kill" that USAir did?
I am a Chairman-level on US and I get upgraded pretty much every time, US miles are also easier to redeem than CO miles. Status-begging is fine, but if this is the new standard, then why bother?
In fact, USAir might not die as a result, but survive due to thinking about it first.... sad thought indeed.
There was a HUGE outcry when AA started "first bag for $15" policy and many predicted that nobody sane will match it - and now everybody is.
So, again, why will others NOT match the "bonus mileage
kill" that USAir did?
I am a Chairman-level on US and I get upgraded pretty much every time, US miles are also easier to redeem than CO miles. Status-begging is fine, but if this is the new standard, then why bother?
In fact, USAir might not die as a result, but survive due to thinking about it first.... sad thought indeed.
#193




Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Pittsburgh
Programs: Whoever Has the Best Bonus
Posts: 5,242
Race to the bottom takes a whole new meaning. I click over to the USAirways forum periodically since they still have a big influence on Pittsburgh and I'm burning through my last set of miles. I will have about 20k left in one account. Now I really don't know if its worth trying to top off since I'll have to pay to use it even if there's availability.
I can somewhat understand all the changes except removing the preferred bonus. USAirways can print their own money (miles) and just keep devaluing the program while still giving 'elites' a bone with extra miles. Instead, they slap them across the face?
I just hope that last one doesn't spread like a virus to other airlines.
I can somewhat understand all the changes except removing the preferred bonus. USAirways can print their own money (miles) and just keep devaluing the program while still giving 'elites' a bone with extra miles. Instead, they slap them across the face?
I just hope that last one doesn't spread like a virus to other airlines.
#194
Moderator: New York City and FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Sep 2007
Programs: AA PPro, Natl EC
Posts: 10,885
So, I was about to compose that email to coair.com to "status-beg", but then I thought: what really prevents all others from matching it?
There was a HUGE outcry when AA started "first bag for $15" policy and many predicted that nobody sane will match it - and now everybody is.
So, again, why will others NOT match the "bonus mileage
kill" that USAir did?
I am a Chairman-level on US and I get upgraded pretty much every time, US miles are also easier to redeem than CO miles. Status-begging is fine, but if this is the new standard, then why bother?
In fact, USAir might not die as a result, but survive due to thinking about it first.... sad thought indeed.
There was a HUGE outcry when AA started "first bag for $15" policy and many predicted that nobody sane will match it - and now everybody is.
So, again, why will others NOT match the "bonus mileage
kill" that USAir did?
I am a Chairman-level on US and I get upgraded pretty much every time, US miles are also easier to redeem than CO miles. Status-begging is fine, but if this is the new standard, then why bother?
In fact, USAir might not die as a result, but survive due to thinking about it first.... sad thought indeed.
While you're correct that the second- and first-bag fee policies have been more widely adopted, the elimination of the 500-mi minimum is one thing that has not been (at least yet). I suspect that a few other airlines may follow suit - those in the most trouble and whose business models do not focus on retaining high-revenue elite frequent flyers. For reasons I stated in another thread, the baggage fees actually provide an opportunity for increased elite retention, since elites are exempt. Cuts that affect elites and only elites, such as the elimination of bonus RDM, decrease elite retention. Apparently, a spreadsheet somewhere indicates that this will be a net positive for US profitability. We'll see...from the sidelines in my case.
#195
Join Date: Jan 2008
Programs: US Dividend Miles
Posts: 333
You know the really weird part about this, from a 'burgh perspective? We Pittsburghers would all be stuck putting up with USAir if they'd stayed loyal to our hub setup. Now I'm feeling sort of thankful that they ditched us and let all the other airlines into our market!

